Nyayaseva
Legal Information, Awareness & Public Resources
Free Legal Information Portal
Legal Information, Awareness & Public Resources
Educational Guide | Important CIC and Court Decisions on RTI
Landmark judgments by the Supreme Court, High Courts, and Central Information Commission (CIC) have shaped the interpretation and scope of the RTI Act, expanding transparency and accountability.
Held: Supreme Court held that right to information is a fundamental right under Article 19(1)(a). This formed the constitutional basis for RTI Act.
Held: Right to information is part of freedom of speech. Citizens have right to know about government affairs.
Held: CIC's orders are binding on public authorities. Non-compliance is contempt of lawful authority.
Held: RTI cannot be used for seeking "reasons" or "justification" for decisions. RTI is for information, not for answers to "why" questions.
Held: Performance appraisal reports of judges are personal information exempted under Section 8(1)(j) and cannot be disclosed.
Held: RBI is a public authority under RTI. Inspection reports of banks can be disclosed in public interest. "No fiduciary relationship with banks."
Held: CJI's office is a public authority. Declaration of judges' assets must be made public (subject to certain conditions).
Held: Mere receipt of land or one-time grant does not make an NGO a public authority. "Substantial financing" means ongoing financial dependence.
Held: CIC held that Indian National Congress, BJP, BSP, NCP, CPI, CPM are public authorities under RTI (currently stayed by Supreme Court).
Held: Parliament is not fully exempt from RTI. Information on utilization of MPLAD funds by MPs must be disclosed.
Held: Details of beneficiaries of government schemes like PMAY must be disclosed unless privacy outweighs public interest.
Held: CIC cannot interfere with judicial matters but can seek information regarding administrative decisions of High Courts.
Held: Right to privacy is fundamental. Personal information unrelated to public activity cannot be disclosed unless larger public interest.